## Prompt: Scoring Error Reasons ### Overview The image presents a prompt designed to evaluate a student's explanation of an error in a problem solution. It outlines the task for an experienced teacher, specifying the need to understand the problem, the incorrect solution, and the ground truth behind the error. The prompt requests a detailed analysis focusing on the alignment between the student's explanation and the actual error. It also provides a structured format for the evaluation, including step-by-step reasoning, student error analysis, and a final decision. ### Components/Axes * **Title:** Prompt for Scoring Error Reasons * **Introduction:** As an experienced {data['Subject']} teacher, your assistance is required to evaluate a student's explanation regarding the error in a problem solution. The task involves a detailed understanding of the problem, the incorrect solution provided, and the ground truth behind the error. Your analysis should focus on whether the student's explanation aligns with the actual error in the solution. * **Details Section:** * Question: {data['Question']} * Incorrect Solution Provided: {data['Model\_Solution\_Steps']} * First Incorrect Step in the Solution: {data['Model\_Solution\_First\_Error\_Step']} * Ground Truth Error Reasons: {data['Model\_Solution\_Error\_Reason']} * Ground Truth Rectified Steps: {data['Model\_Solution\_Rectified\_First\_Error\_Step']} * Student's Explanation of the Error: {data['Evaluation\_Result']['error\_reason']} * **Instructions Section:** * Step-by-Step Reasoning: \[Offer a succinct, step-by-step interpretation of the ground truth error reason.] * Student Error Reason Analysis: \[Analyze the student's explanation step by step, determining its accuracy in reflecting the actual error briefly.] * Final Decision: \[State only 'Correct' or 'Wrong' to conclude whether the student's explanation correctly identifies the error based on your analysis.] * **Concluding Statement:** Please follow this format without any additional introductory or concluding statements. ### Detailed Analysis or ### Content Details The prompt is structured to guide the evaluation of a student's explanation of an error. It begins by setting the context and defining the evaluator's role. It then lists the specific details needed for the evaluation, including the question, the incorrect solution, the first incorrect step, the ground truth error reasons, the ground truth rectified steps, and the student's explanation. Finally, it provides a structured format for the evaluation, requiring step-by-step reasoning, student error analysis, and a final decision. ### Key Observations The prompt uses placeholders (e.g., {data['Subject']}) to indicate where specific information should be inserted. The instructions are clear and concise, providing a structured approach to evaluating the student's explanation. The prompt emphasizes the importance of aligning the student's explanation with the actual error in the solution. ### Interpretation The prompt is designed to ensure a consistent and thorough evaluation of student explanations of errors. By providing a structured format and specific details, it aims to reduce subjectivity and improve the accuracy of the evaluation. The use of placeholders allows for the prompt to be adapted to different subjects and problems. The prompt's focus on aligning the student's explanation with the actual error highlights the importance of understanding the underlying reasons for errors in problem-solving.